Student Achievement

Does School Choice Actually Improve Education?

One of the biggest arguments for school choice is that competition will encourage schools to improve. However, the research doesn't always support that claim.

Canbolat (2021) studied Indiana's school voucher program over eight years. Public schools initially showed some improvement, but those gains did not last. Eventually, achievement declined in schools facing greater voucher competition.

Mills and Wolf (2017) studied Louisiana's voucher program and found negative effects on student achievement during the first two years, especially in math. This challenges the idea that transferring to a private school automatically leads to better results.

However, Egalite and Catt (2025) found little evidence that Indiana's voucher program had a meaningful positive or negative impact on the average public school student's academic achievement or graduation rate.

Not all achievement studies use the same measures: