Segregation and Inequality

Does School Choice Give Every Student the Same Opportunities?

School choice is often presented as an opportunity for all families. However, having choices available doesn't necessarily mean every family can take advantage of them.

Edwards and Anderson (2025) studied school choice in Michigan and found that increased charter school enrollment was connected to greater racial and economic segregation among schools within districts. Their findings for students transferring between school districts were more mixed.

Marcotte and Dalane (2019) also found that charter school growth contributed to increased economic segregation, although the estimated impact was fairly small.

Crema (2026) found that charter school openings were associated with increased racial segregation within nearby public school classrooms. This research shows that school choice can affect more than just where children attend school. It can also affect who they learn alongside.

Why This Matters to Me

One of the things I love most about teaching in a diverse Title I school is that my students come from all different backgrounds. They learn from one another every day.

I worry that expanding school choice could create more separation between students based on race and family income. Families may have different access to transportation, tuition money, and nearby schools.