Annotated Bibliography
Canbolat, Y. (2021). The long-term effect of competition on public school achievement: Evidence from the Indiana Choice Scholarship Program. Education Policy Analysis Archives, 29, Article 97. https://doi.org/10.14507/epaa.29.6311
Annotation: Student Achievement
This study looks at how Indiana's school voucher program affected achievement in traditional public schools. The researcher examined eight years of math and reading scores to see whether competition from private schools helped or hurt public schools.
At first, schools facing more competition showed some improvement, but those gains did not last. Over time, achievement declined. The study also found evidence that higher-achieving students were more likely to leave through the voucher program, which may partly explain the changing test scores.
This caught my attention because supporters often say competition will push public schools to improve. The research suggests that what looks promising at first may not hold up over time.
I would use this article on my website to discuss the students who remain in public schools when others leave. It makes me question whether competition is always the best way to improve education. These findings come from Indiana, so they do not tell us exactly what will happen in Alabama, but they give us something important to think about as the CHOOSE Act grows.
Chin, M. J., & Chen, A. (2026). Impacts of school choice expansion on public school finance, inputs, voter tax preferences, and achievement. American Educational Research Journal. Advance online publication. https://doi.org/10.3102/00028312261468354
Annotation: Public School Funding
This study examines how school choice expansion in Indiana affected public school funding, resources, and achievement. The researchers compared districts facing more competition from private and charter schools with districts facing less. They reviewed spending, student performance, classroom conditions, and local tax efforts.
Districts facing more competition lost revenue and reduced spending. Some experienced larger classes and school closures. Communities tried to raise additional money through local taxes, but that did not fully cover the losses. Early academic gains also faded over time.
This connects to one of my biggest concerns about school choice. Public schools already stretch their budgets to provide teachers, special education services, intervention programs, and supplies. I worry about asking them to do the same work with fewer resources.
I would use this study to explain the financial challenges that may come with expanding school choice. It also makes me wonder whether Alabama could face similar issues under the CHOOSE Act. Since the study looks at Indiana's policies, I would be careful not to assume the effects will be exactly the same here.
Crema, A. (2026). The segregative effects of charter schools. American Economic Journal: Economic Policy, 18, (2), 242–274. https://doi.org/10.1257/pol.20230539
Annotation: Segregation and Inequality
This study examines whether charter schools affect racial segregation in nearby public school classrooms. The researcher studied almost 100 elementary charter school openings in North Carolina from 1997 to 2015. Instead of looking only at school-wide enrollment, the study examined how children were grouped into individual classrooms.
The findings connected announcements of new charter schools with increased racial segregation within nearby public schools. The effects were stronger in some communities, including places where White students were not the majority. The researcher also noted that the overall effects were relatively small.
This interested me because I teach in a diverse Title I school, and I see that diversity as a strength. My students work with classmates from different racial, cultural, and economic backgrounds every day. They learn things from one another that go beyond our lessons.
I would use this study to show that school choice can change more than enrollment numbers. It can also change who learns together in the same classroom. This research is about charter schools, not private-school vouchers, so it cannot directly tell us what Alabama's CHOOSE Act will do. Still, it raises important questions about equity.
Edwards, D. S., & Anderson, K. P. (2025). Do public school choice policies segregate schools? Dynamic effects in Michigan. AERA Open, 11. https://doi.org/10.1177/23328584251314049
Annotation: Segregation and Inequality
This study looks at how school choice affected racial and economic segregation in Michigan. The researchers examined charter schools and programs that let students transfer between public school districts. They used enrollment data collected over several years to see whether these choices brought students together or separated them.
Greater charter school enrollment was linked to more racial and economic segregation among schools within districts. The results for transfers between districts were mixed: segregation increased in some settings but decreased in others.
This article stood out because I believe public schools should bring children from all backgrounds together. I teach in a diverse Title I school, and I see students learning from different experiences, cultures, and perspectives every day.
I would use this research to ask whether school choice really creates equal opportunities. A family may technically have more options but still lack transportation, money, or access to a nearby school. I think those barriers matter when we discuss who benefits. The results come from Michigan's charter and public transfer policies, though, so they should not be treated as direct evidence about Alabama's private-school program.
Egalite, A. J., & Catt, A. D. (2025). Effects of the Indiana Choice Scholarship Program on public school students' achievement and graduation rates. AERA Open, 11. https://doi.org/10.1177/23328584251326927
Annotation: Student Achievement
This study examines whether Indiana's voucher program affected students who stayed in public schools. The researchers used student data from the 2006–2007 through 2015–2016 school years, looking at math, reading, and graduation rates. They compared schools facing different levels of competition from private schools.
Unlike some other studies, this research found little evidence that voucher competition helped or hurt the average public school student's academic results. Overall, the researchers did not find major changes in achievement or graduation rates during the period studied.
I want to include this article because not all research comes to the same conclusion. I have concerns about school choice, but I also know the effects can depend on how a program is designed and funded.
I would use this article to give another perspective on my website. It also makes me wonder whether test scores tell the whole story. Even when scores stay about the same, schools may still face changes in staffing, funding, and services. Those things matter to teachers and students, too. Since the study ended in 2015–2016, it cannot tell us what later expansions will do.
Marcotte, D. E., & Dalane, K. (2019). Socioeconomic segregation and school choice in American public schools. Educational Researcher, 48, (8), 493–503. https://doi.org/10.3102/0013189X19879714
Annotation: Segregation and Inequality
This article looks at how charter school growth relates to economic segregation in public education. The researchers used school district data from 1998 to 2015, comparing where students from different income groups attended school. Free lunch eligibility helped identify students from lower-income families.
Economic segregation increased during those years, especially in large districts. The researchers also found a connection between charter school growth and greater separation of students by income, although the estimated effect was fairly small.
This matters to me because I believe public schools should provide opportunities for every child, regardless of family income. School choice may sound equal on paper, but families do not all have the same transportation, finances, or nearby options.
Teaching in a Title I school has shown me how much families depend on public education. I would use this study to discuss whether expanding school choice could create bigger differences between schools and the students they serve. The findings focus on charter schools, not vouchers, so I would use them to raise questions about equity rather than claim they predict the effects of Alabama's CHOOSE Act.
Mills, J. N., & Wolf, P. J. (2017). Vouchers in the bayou: The effects of the Louisiana Scholarship Program on student achievement after 2 years. Educational Evaluation and Policy Analysis, 39, (3), 464–484. https://doi.org/10.3102/0162373717693108
Annotation: Student Achievement
This study looks at whether Louisiana students who used private-school vouchers performed better academically. The program served lower-income students attending low-performing public schools. Researchers used an experimental design to compare outcomes and estimate what happened when students used vouchers to move to private schools.
During the first two years, voucher users experienced declines in math and reading achievement. Those negative effects became smaller in the second year, but the results still raised concerns about assuming a private school will improve student performance.
This surprised me because one of the biggest arguments for school choice is that another school will offer a better education. The study shows that changing schools does not automatically lead to better test scores.
I would use this article to ask whether voucher programs are improving opportunities and how participating schools are held accountable. If public money pays for private education, I think families deserve to know whether students are learning. This study only examined the program's early years and the students who used vouchers, so it cannot answer every question about long-term effects on public schools.
Monarrez, T., Kisida, B., & Chingos, M. (2022). The effect of charter schools on school segregation. American Economic Journal: Economic Policy, 14, (1), 301–340. https://doi.org/10.1257/pol.20190682
Annotation: Segregation and Inequality
This study examines whether charter school growth has increased racial segregation in public education. Researchers compared enrollment patterns to see how often students from different racial and ethnic backgrounds attended school together. They also studied how these patterns changed as charter schools expanded.
Charter growth was linked to modest increases in segregation for several groups. Black and Hispanic students became less likely to attend school with students from other racial backgrounds in some settings. However, the study also found that charter schools sometimes reduced segregation between districts.
This connects to my concerns about protecting diversity in public education. I believe students benefit from classmates with different cultures, backgrounds, and experiences. In my classroom, those everyday interactions teach lessons that go beyond academics.
I would use this research to show how school choice can influence who attends school together. The findings are not all one-sided, and I think that's important to acknowledge. Since this study looks at charter schools rather than private-school vouchers, I would connect it to the larger school choice debate without claiming it proves what will happen under Alabama's CHOOSE Act.